Shoggoth2588 blog header photo
Shoggoth2588's c-blog
Fronts 1Posts 1526Blogs 124Following 0Followers 23



Band of Bloggers August 2021 Theme


Whether you love them or hate them I think we can all agree on these two aspects of games journalism; Review scores are awful, and review scores are very difficult to ignore. For this month’s Band of Bloggers prompt I’m going to appeal to your inner contrarian by asking you to tell me about all of those times the critics and reviews were wrong! 


This month’s prompt is meant to be fun, but I fully understand that some of the takes you or I bring up might be kind of spicy, so I’ll throw out some softer, cooler takes as examples. For example, The Last of Us is not a perfect 10/10 game, especially when it was originally reviewed on the Playstation 3. Zombie apocalypses had been done to death well before June 2013, focusing on a heartwarming plot and characters and the drama of a zombie apocalypse too had been done to death (most notably in gaming by TT’s The Walking Dead). This was also a game that featured crafting which, after Tomb Raider (2013), Far Cry 3, and Dead Rising 3, didn’t make The Last of Us stand out. It all worked well enough, and if you connected with the characters maybe you thought it was a perfect 10, but I saw it as a 4 or 5.




I was going to cite Senua’s Sacrifice as an example because of that time Jim Sterling gave it a 1 out of 10. In fact, I disagree with a lot of the scores Jimbo has given out, but what really got under my skin was giving Arkham Origins a 3.5 but giving Pokemon X and Y a 9.5. Both games are derivative sequels that use established gameplay and characters to set up a story that doesn’t really offer much in the way of stakes, neither are particularly well optimized, and both games are perfectly fine. I thought maybe Jim reviewed the PC port of Arkham Origins, which was notoriously bug-ridden but apparently he went with the Xbox 360 version (which was also glitchy).




As for Pokemon, it seems like the review on Destructoid opened by saying Pokemon isn’t meant to change and players would be wrong to expect a different gameplay and narrative structure. Arkham Origins isn’t a 3.5, but I would put it closer to a 6, especially given how patched it is at this point. I would rate Pokemon X and Y similarly, 6 or 6.5 because even though it’s a really pretty game the main innovation is to make the experience easier, and that’s before mega evolution completely trivializes the combat. 




I’m going to leave the rest to you! My examples might have been a little bit hotter than I intended, but it doesn’t have to be like that at all. Even if you think a 7.5 is a 7, or an 8 is a 9, I’d love to hear about those games that you think were given the wrong review score...like that time Chris gave the best Zelda game of all time a 6.5, no Chris, I haven’t forgotten about that Chris! Just make sure when you post your blog or Qtoid update to mark it with a #BOB or #BandofBloggers. Stay cool everyone!



Login to vote this up!


LaTerry   44
Nior   22
Just Aaron   4



Please login (or) make a quick account (free)
to view and post comments.

 Login with Twitter

 Login with Dtoid

Three day old threads are only visible to verified humans - this helps our small community management team stay on top of spam

Sorry for the extra step!


About Shoggoth2588one of us since 6:55 AM on 06.03.2013

Hello all! I'm Joe, from Maryland! I released five days before Enix launched Dragon Quest 3! I started playing games around the time I was 3, with some very early memories of myself playing Duck Hunt in my Dad's office and Golden Axe in an arcade at what might have been an airport (It was a weird memory). I'm mostly harmless so if you wanna talk to me, send me a message. I'll be around, making horrible puns though not quite as horrible as Gus' is able to do. I'll lurk on the Discord too and if you want to be my friend there, than come at me!

Discord: Shoggoth88#1113

Ryzen 5 1600
6 core 3.2GHz
Radeon RX 570
24GB Ram
Windows 10 Home 64bit