TurboKill blog header photo
TurboKill's c-blog
Fronts 2Posts 539Blogs 9Following 0Followers 15



Emotionally blunted? Maybe blame something besides video games


I am fairly sure you are all well-initiated to the video games x violence discussion. If not, here's a crash course: Something something Jack Thompson, Mortal Kombat, ESRB, yadda yadda "bad parenting", mumble grumble "desensitization to violence", the "American Psychological Association said it's bad", and lastly "that one shooter played Counter Strike a lot".

Did I miss anything?

Oh, and you can literally find people complaining about paper becoming readily available.

The current development is that researchers were studying a group of young men aged around the early twenties. Participants were monitored via fMRI scans to find if the players who enjoyed their violent games were more emotionally desensitized than the others. The control group were the ones with no experience playing violent games on a regular basis. The rest frequently spent nearly 5 hours a day playing violent games such as "Call of Duty and Battlefield". Subsequently, no difference was found between the violent game players and those who didn't play violent games.

The players were shown "emotionally positive, negative, and neutral" photos and their fMRI scans showed virtually no difference between the two groups of players. The researchers found that the participants' reactions to each category of photos were the same across the board. The positive and negative photos garnered much more brain activity than the neutral ones.

 Pictured: A room full of people that should be on some kind of watchlist. Utterly horrifying.

Personally, I'm more interested in reading about the effects of playing games five hours a day, once you're out of school anyways, but that's just me. I would also like to know why the study only worked with young adult males and not females. Couldn't they have looked up the actual average demographics? No really, I just google'd "average video game player" and the first link clearly states that males only encompass 52% of players. Unless the relatively recent women's march involved marching out of the country, then I think the statistic is still fairly accurate.

Questionable sampling aside, the findings are fairly convincing that theories about violent games leading to emotional desensitization should be reconsidered.

Despite their findings failing to find a correlation with constant exposure to violent games and emotional desensitization, many studies have found interesting results regarding gaming and changed behavior. I know the incessant stories about the mental effects of modern media can be really tiring, but the human brain is a really complex beast. On occasion, the results of these studies can even be somewhat fascinating. For example, here's a fun tidbit: Did you know that researchers found that children who played "pro-social" games such as Super Mario Sunshine were found to exhibit more pro-social behavior later on? That's pretty nice to hear, a breath of fresh air from research regarding games like Mortal Kombat anyways. 

I wonder where Katamari Damacy falls. I blame that game for my minor hoarding tendencies.

Ultimately, this study does not completely refute the APA study which found a correlation to violent games and aggression, but it will no less be used in many a comment thread as defacto proof otherwise. Researchers acknowledge that there's still the possibility that the players may not display different brain activity, but could still act differently. However, it is good to know that the science isn't yet done.

Like many of you, I look forward to when games aren't always getting such negative attention, so it is pretty nice to see that several studies out there are affirming that our games are not secretly Satan causing us to turn into husks. Let's be glad that Jack Thompson isn't on the news every other day anymore either.

Back to restraining myself from throwing the controller while playing Ninja Gaiden.

Source: The British Psychological Society Research Digest

- Also cocks.

Login to vote this up!


Agent9   20
Gajknight   19
LaTerry   16
Voodoome   10
Michael Giff   6
Scrustle   5



Please login (or) make a quick account (free)
to view and post comments.

 Login with Twitter

 Login with Dtoid

Three day old threads are only visible to verified humans - this helps our small community management team stay on top of spam

Sorry for the extra step!


About TurboKillone of us since 3:45 PM on 04.11.2008

I first discovered Destructoid through RetroforceGO! and their Halloween '07 episode, fell in love, finally registered in April of '08, and I have stuck around ever since.

I frequently perform professionally (or teach) around my area as a double bassist for some of my local symphony orchestras and other places that are willing to pay up.


Dtoid Community Completed Games Master List

[Archived] Edition of Dtoid CCG
Front Page'd:

Unsung Masterpieces

Faking It: Finishing Games

Some of my favorite games and series:

Link to the Past, Chrono Trigger, Final Fantasy (Especially XIV), Dark Souls, Demon's Souls, Bloodborne, Sekiro, ANYTHING SOULS, Alien: Isolation, Pokemon, Shadow Madness, Metal Arms: Glitch in the System, Elder Scrolls (Including Online), GTA: San Andreas, Undertale, Dragon Quest V, Kingdom Come: Deliverance

and countless others because I suck at picking favorites.

PC Specs:
Desktop -- i7-9700k, RTX 3070, 32 GB RAM @ 3000mhz
Laptop -- i9-10980HK, RTX 2080 Super, 32 GB RAM

Want to know more about me? Check out my interview from the DTOID Interviews series. It was seven years ago, but oh well:

En Garde, TurboKill!